There has been a lot written about the problems of FATCA
recently. The financial institutions
which will be subject to the new law have complained about the burden (in both
time and costs) of reporting the information, and the fact that the anticipated
IRS revenue receipts (estimated at $8 billion over 10 years – which is not a
huge amount of money for a nation the size of the US) are probably outweighed
by the costs of implementation. Americans expats (and in particular those who
hold dual citizenship) are starting to appreciate the difficulties in opening
bank or investment accounts overseas and are resentful of the fact that America
is the only one of the leading industrialized nations which requires its
citizens to pay US taxes even if they live outside the United States.
But one aspect about which there has been surprisingly little fuss is the
security implications for Americans living abroad. When FATCA becomes fully effective, foreign
financial institutions will have to submit detailed annual reports on their
American customers with bank accounts of more than $50,000, including cash
balances, receipts, and withdrawals.
In order to meet all of the FATCA data gathering and reporting requirements FATCA
will require the banks to keep data on a plethora of information including residential
addresses, green card status and even the names of the Americans’ relatives. The information is far, far more detailed than
that which has been previously held by any financial institution with which I
have ever had dealings. Never before
would the banks have had to gather and isolate such detailed records
specifically relating to US citizens.
The US is a nation which is, post 9/11, usually somewhat
obsessed with security. And not without
good reason. It is a powerful country
which has made a lot of enemies in recent years, and it usually takes the
safety of its people very seriously.
Who might find it useful to have a database of all of the
American residents in their territory? Might
perhaps a jihadist group in Afghanistan be interested to know where all of the
US persons in Afghanistan live? Might a
South American kidnapping group be interested in a list which shows the cash
balances held by US citizens in their territory, and the names of their
relatives? Might an anti-capitalist
extremist be interested in being given the private and business details of a US
resident business mogul near them?
Of course the data that the financial institutions gather should
be kept confidential. But bank IT
systems are only as confidential as the employees who have to access them. The IRS and HMRC (who are likely to follow
the US in implementing FATCA-type legislation) know this already – indeed, they
both make very good use of it by encouraging and even paying handsome cash
rewards to whistle-blowers. So if the
IRS know they can get information from the banks by offering employees cash
incentives to blow the whistle on wrong-doing, what on earth makes them think
that Al-Qaeda can’t employ the same techniques with very different aims?
By introducing legislation designed to stop tax cheats in their tracks, the US
may be unwittingly putting at risk the lives of many of their expatriate
citizens. It seems that being seen publicly
to take a tough stance on tax cheats takes a higher priority in these
straightened times than the security of US citizens abroad.
The UK has a huge number of expats based in countries all over
the world – including a large number of relatively unstable locations where
corruption is rife. The UK government
would do well to consider this important aspect of security before deciding
simply to follow a “me too” strategy and take the same route as the US.